Title conditions
The table belows lists previous Lands Tribunal for Scotland decisions under the jurisdiction of title conditions. Cases are listed by name and by Lands Tribunal reference number, with the most recent cases first. Selecting a case will either
- open a summary of the case with brief details of the decision reached — at the end of the summary you will find a link to the formal “Opinion” or “Note” of the Tribunal, which comprises the full statement of reasons for the decision; or
- open the full Opinion or Note, which may include a headnote with key phrases that will help indicate the specific type of issues dealt with in that case.
Note: Those cases with a reference number commencing “LTS/LO/” were originally lodged under the Conveyancing and Feudal Reform (Scotland) Act 1970, but were heard by the Tribunal after the coming into force of the Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003. Accordingly, they were dealt with as if they were applications under the 2003 Act.
| Case Name | Reference No. |
|---|---|
| Kevin and Ailien Pallot v David and Jacklyn Carter | LTS/TC/2019/29 |
| Nicholas-Ann Duffus v Malcolm Allan Housebuilders Limited | LTS/TC/2019/21 |
| Sheena Borthwick Toomey and Alan Toomey v Wilson Smith and Claire Hall | LTS/TC/2019/18 |
| Peter Alexander Leslie v National Grid Gas plc (Merits) | LTS/TC/2019/11 |
| Peter Alexander Leslie v National Grid Gas plc (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2019/11 |
| Catherine Nicol v Karen Crowley | LTS/TC/2019/09 |
| Lindsay Robertson Savage v Bridget Joanna Thomson | LTS/TC/2019/02 |
| Leehand Properties Limited | LTS/TC/2019/01 |
| Michael Scott Christie and Lisa Mary Christie v Brian Michael Carroll and Samantha Jane Smith and others (Merits) | LTS/TC/2018/36 |
| Michael Scott Christie and Lisa Mary Christie v Brian Michael Carroll and Samantha Jane Smith and others (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2018/36 |
| Scottish Ministers (per Tayside Health Board) v (1) Brechin Healthcare Group (2) City of Brechin and District Community Council (3) The Don Centenary Trust | LTS/TC/2018/24 |
| Mary O’Gorman v John Love and Margaret Love | LTS/TC/2018/23 |
| Mark Cadman and Sheena Stevenson v (First) Mark Cook and Mary Rodgers, and (Second) Gavin Miller and Tracey Miller | LTS/TC/2018/21 |
| Kevin Mahoney and Barbara Mahoney v Roy Cumming and Helen Cumming (Merits) | LTS/TC/2018/16 |
| Kevin Mahoney and Barbara Mahoney v Roy Cumming and Helen Cumming (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2018/16 |
| Inchcolm Land Limited | LTS/TC/2018/15 |
| Danny Lai Chung Chan and Katherine Mei Kwan Hau v Christina Sanderson–Tolsma and Others | LTS/TC/2018/12 |
| Ian Martin & Margaret Henderson Martin v Mrs Josephine Turnbull, and Niall Ross Macmillan and Another | LTS/TC/2018/01 |
| Mark Cadman and Sheena Stevenson v (First) Mark Cook and Mary Rodgers, and (Second) Gavin Miller and Tracey Miller | LTS/TC/2017/33 |
| Romano Crolla v Robert Reid | LTS/TC/2017/32 |
| James O’Donnell v Thomas Edward Craig and Others | LTS/TC/2017/18 |
| Keith Bennett v Iain Skene | LTS/TC91/2017/05 |
| Rubislaw Quarry Aberdeen Limited v (First) Hill Of Rubislaw (Q Seven) Limited, (Second) Barry Stuart Clarkson, (Third) Paul Michael Clarkson, (Fourth) Stuart Andrew Clarkson, (Fifth) Alan Massie (Merits) | LTS/TC/2016/35 |
| Rubislaw Quarry Aberdeen Limited v (First) Hill Of Rubislaw (Q Seven) Limited, (Second) Barry Stuart Clarkson, (Third) Paul Michael Clarkson, (Fourth) Stuart Andrew Clarkson, (Fifth) Alan Massie (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2016/35 |
| Mrs Kim Thomson MacDonald, Executor of the late John Thomson | LTS/TC/2016/01 |
| Andrew and Annabella Yule v Michael Tobert (Merits) | LTS/TC/2015/10 |
| Andrew and Annabella Yule v Michael Tobert (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2015/10 |
| United Investment Company Limited v Charlie Reid Travel Limited | LTS/TC/2015/01 |
| Ferguson v Gunby and Nelson | LTS/TC/2014/30 |
| Michael Joseph Marriott and another v Greenbelt Group Limited (Merits) | LTS/TC/2014/27 |
| Michael Joseph Marriott and another v Greenbelt Group Limited (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2014/27 |
| Margaret MacKay v Ronald McGowan and another (Merits) | LTS/TC/2014/03 |
| Margaret MacKay v Ronald McGowan and another (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2014/03 |
| Duffus and Others v McWhirter | LTS/TC/2013/34 |
| Trustees of John W Raeside & Son v Chalmers & Fraser | LTS/TC/2013/29 |
| Pollacchi v Campbell | LTS/TC/2013/24 |
| David Grant and another v National Trust for Scotland (Merits) | LTS/TC/2013/23 |
| David Grant and another v National Trust for Scotland (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2013/23 |
| David Sinton and another v Philip Lloyd and another | LTS/TC/2013/17 |
| Primrose Young v Mark Markey and Another | LTS/TC/2013/08 |
| Mark Cook and Mary Rodgers & Others v Mark Cadman | LTS/TC/2013/04, 06 |
| Branziet Investments v Paul and Heather Anderson | LTS/TC/2012/35 |
| Benjamin Mackay and Another v John Bain and Another | LTS/TC/2012/24 |
| Paul Franklin and another v David Alexander Lawson (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2012/23 |
| Paul Franklin and another v David Alexander Lawson (Merits) | LTS/TC/2012/23 |
| James Anthony Macneil and Others v Bradonwood Limited | LTS/TC/2012/22 |
| Bruce Smith & Another v Martin Alan Properties Limited (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2012/14 |
| Iain Stewart and Others v Mary Sherwood and Another | LTS/TC91/2012/09 |
| William Wilson and Mrs Heidi Wilson v Scottish Borders Housing Association Limited (Compensation) | LTS/TC/2012/08 |
| William McCabe v Duncan Killcross & Another | LTS/TC91/2012/04 |
| Lily Jane Scott & Others v Barry Applin & Others | LTS/TC91/2012/03 |
| Gilfin Property Holdings Limited & Others v Patricia Beech | LTS/TC91/2012/02 |
| Cope & others and Stock & another v Ms X (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2012/02 |
| Cope & others and Stock & another v Ms X (Merits) | LTS/TC/2012/02 |
| Patterson & Others v Drouet & Others | LTS/TC91/2012/01 |
| Michael Stephenson & Another v Graham Thomas & Another (Merits) | LTS/TC/2011/42 |
| (i) Executor of Michael Stephenson & (ii) Geraldine S Chamberlain v Graham Thomas & Another (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2011/42 |
| Hossack v Robertson | LTS/TC/2011/40 |
| William MacDonald and Christine Rachel MacDonald v George James Murdoch | LTS/TC/2011/30 |
| David Stirling & Irene Allan v Guy Thorley & Others | LTS/TC/2011/26 |
| Elizabeth McNab v Alexander Smith (Merits) | LTS/TC/2011/24 |
| Elizabeth McNab v Alexander Smith (Compensation) | LTS/TC/2011/24 |
| Elizabeth McNab v Alexander Smith (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2011/24 |
| McCulloch v Reid and Manning | LTS/TC/2011/19 |
| Scott Gibson v Andrew and Elizabeth Anderson | LTS/TC/2011/15 |
| Iain Rennie and Dr Jean Rennie v Cullen House Gardens Limited | LTS/TC/2011/09 |
| Trigstone Limited & Others v Hugh Mackenzie & Others | LTS/TC/2011/08 |
| Gordon Watt & Another v Eric Garden & Others | LTS/TC/2011/03 |
| Lee Scott Davenport and Kay Elaine Davenport v Julian Hodge Bank Limited and Others | LTS/TC/2010/39 |
| Donald Parkin and Another v Martin Kennedy | LTS/TC/2010/38 |
| Whitelaw v Acheson (2) | LTS/TC/2010/29 |
| Whitelaw v Acheson | LTS/TC/2010/29 |
| Stuart Fyfe and Another v Aileen Benson and Others | LTS/TC/2010/25 |
| James Jarron and Another v Robert Stuart and Another | LTS/TC/2010/18 |
| Patterson & Let’s Direct (Scotland) Limited v Drouet & Others | LTS/TC/2010/09 & 11 |
| Corstorphine & Shand v Fleming & Others | LTS/TC/2010/06 |
| ATD Developments Limited v Weir and Hettrick | LTS/TC/2010/03 |
| I & H Brown Limited, Applicants | LTS/TC/2010/02 |
| Antony Brown and Janice Brown v Mr and Mrs J M Kitchen and Others | LTS/TC/2009/46 |
| Chisholm v Crawford (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2009/42 |
| Herbert Adams v Trustees for the Linton Village Hall | LTS/TC/2009/41 |
| Trevor Barr and James Sharp v Annabel Macrae (Merits) | LTS/TC/2009/37, 38, 39 |
| Trevor Barr and James Sharp v Annabel Macrae | LTS/TC/2009/37, 38, 39 |
| Parkin v Kennedy (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2009/35 |
| Steven Corry and Gillian Corry v Derek MacLachlan and Vanessa Paynton (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2009/28 |
| Bryan R Kennedy v Abbey Lane Properties and the Partners and Trustees thereof | LTS/TC/2009/26 |
| Tower Hotel (Troon) Limited v David And Karen McCann and William S Doodson | LTS/TC/2009/23 |
| G v A (Merits, Compensation and Expenses) (Parties not named to protect identities) | LTS/TC/2009/13 |
| Walter Harkness and Another v Senator Homes Limited and Another | LTS/TC/2009/11 |
| Co-operative Group Limited v (1) Propinvest Asset Management and (2) Thistle Investments Limited and Others | LTS/TC/2009/09 |
| Perth & Kinross Council v Chapman and Oxnard | LTS/TC/2009/06 |
| Robert Fleeman v David Lyon and Joanne Lyon | LTS/TC/2008/60 |
| Colin John Patrick Scott and Others v Graham Michael Teasdale and Others (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2008/56 |
| Jennifer Mary Gibb v Karen Kerr (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2008/54 |
| Kevin Clarke and Another v Sigrid-Kristin Grantham (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2008/49 |
| Matnic Limited v Charles Armstrong | LTS/TC/2008/46 |
| Carol Graham and Another v John Lee and Another (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2008/41 |
| Faeley v Clark and Doull (No 2) (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2008/40 |
| Francis Faeley and Another v Elizabeth Doull and Others (Compensation) | LTS/TC/2008/40 |
| John Colecliffe and Another v Richard Thompson | LTS/TC/2008/38 |
| Douglas Cassidy and Another v Hugh H McAdam and Others (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2008/33 |
| Mark Thomas Hollinshead and Jill Marie Hollinshead v Jeremy Graham Gilchrist | LTS/TC/2008/31 |
| Greenbelt Property Limited v John Riggens and Another | LTS/TC/2008/30 |
| A. Murray & Sons Limited v Munro and Others | LTS/TC/2008/27 |
| Thomas Smith and Another as Trustees for Ballantyne Property Services v Norman Lawrence and Others (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2008/18 |
| Iver Hooper and Another v William Sinclair and Another | LTS/TC/2008/13 |
| James McKenzie & Another v Hilary Scott & Others | LTS/TC/2008/12 |
| David Fenwick & Others v National Trust for Scotland & Others (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC91/2008/03 |
| Matthew Dalby and Catherine Dalby v John Bracken | LTS/TC/2007/51 |
| Esplin and Baird v Higgitt and Others (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2007/48 |
| William J. Kirkwood and Robert Kirkwood v Kim Thomson and Others (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2007/44 |
| Margaret-Anne Melville v Norna Crabbe and Another | LTS/TC/2007/42 |
| Verrico v Tomlinson and Findlay | LTS/TC/2007/37 |
| Lejf Jensen v Jonathon Tyler and Linda Tyler (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2007/35 |
| Alexandra McClumpha v Alexander Bradie | LTS/TC/2007/34 |
| Margaret Cocozza v Lawrence Rutherford and Others | LTS/TC/2007/33 |
| McGregor v Collins-Taylor | LTS/TC/2007/32 |
| Lackie v Sloss and Others | LTS/TC/2007/30 |
| Blackman and Matheson v Best and Others | LTS/TC/2007/29 |
| Lawrie and Ronald v Mashford | LTS/TC/2007/28 |
| Ritchie v Douglas and Others | LTS/TC/2007/26 |
| MacNab v McDowall | LTS/TC/2007/23 |
| Hamilton v Robertson and Others | LTS/TC/2007/21 |
| Mark Gallacher and Another v George Wood (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2007/02 |
| George David Cattanach and Kathleen Josephine Whitton Cattanach v Francis Newman Vine-Hall and Joan Vine-Hall | LTS/TC/2006/62 |
| Council for Music in Hospitals and Others v Trustees for Richard Gerard Associates | LTS/TC/2006/61 and 2007/01 |
| Wilson v McNamee | LTS/TC/2006/57 |
| David Brown and Another v Mark Richardson and Another | LTS/TC/2006/41 |
| David Brown and Another v Mark Richardson and Another (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2006/41 |
| Graham and Fletcher v Parker | LTS/TC/2006/25 |
| Smith v Elrick and Gerrard | LTS/TC/2006/14 |
| Peter Trodden v James Cogle (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2006/13 |
| At.home Nationwide Limited v Catherine Morris and Others | LTS/TC/2006/12 |
| Smith v Prior and Others (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2006/06 |
| Daniel Gerard Anderson and Another v Elaine McKinnon (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2006/04 |
| Sheltered Housing Management Limited v Margaret Forbes Jack (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2006/01 |
| Sheltered Housing Management Limited v Margaret Forbes Jack (Compensation) | LTS/TC/2006/01 |
| Sheltered Housing Management Limited v Margaret Forbes Jack | LTS/TC/2006/01 |
| Faeley and Another v Clark and Others | LTS/TC/2005/30 |
| West Coast Property Developments Limited v Clarke and Others | LTS/TC/2005/21 |
| West Coast Property Developments Limited v Clarke and Others (Expenses) | LTS/TC/2005/21 |
| McPherson and Another v Mackie and Others | LTS/TC/2005/18 & 19 |
| Daly and Another v Bryce and Another | LTS/TC/2005/15 |
| J & L Leisure Limited v Shaw | LTS/TC/2005/12 |
| Donnelly and Regan v Mullen and Others (Merits and Expenses) | LTS/TC/2005/01 |
| George Wimpey East Scotland Limited v Fleming and Others (Merits and Compensation) | LTS/LO/2004/19 |
| Church of Scotland General Trustees v McLaren and Another | LTS/LO/2004/17 & 18 |
| Ord v Mashford and Others | LTS/LO/2004/16 |